Getting a new roof is a big decision that affects more than just your home’s appearance. It impacts curb appeal, energy efficiency, and weather protection, making it a significant investment. When comparing a metal roof vs. asphalt shingles, both options have their own set of advantages and disadvantages.
But in the end, the best choice for your home will depend on your preferences, climate, and budget. To help you out, this blog post will outline the main differences between metal roofs and shingles to help you choose the best option for your home.
Metal Roofs
Both residential and commercial structures frequently have metal roofs because they are a strong and adaptable choice. Given that they are made of steel, aluminum, copper, or zinc, they are able to withstand harsh weather conditions including fire, strong winds, and heavy rain.
Compared to asphalt shingles, metal roofs require less care and frequently last over 50 years or longer. In warmer climates, their ability to reflect light also lowers cooling expenses. Metal roofs also come in a variety of designs and hues, giving them the ability to highlight any building’s appearance in addition to providing durable protection.
Types Of Metal Roofs
A. Standing Seam Metal Roofs
Vertical panels with concealed fasteners give standing seam metal roofs a sleek, modern look. Raised seams enhance water resistance and durability while allowing for thermal expansion, making it a low-maintenance choice for contemporary homes.
B. Corrugated Metal Roofs
Corrugated metal roofs feature wavy panels that provide strength while being lightweight and affordable. Made from galvanized steel or aluminum, these roofs can last over 40 years and drain water efficiently. However, exposed fasteners may lead to leaks if it’s not maintained
C. Stone-Coated Metal Roofs
With a steel base coated in stone granules, stone-coated metal roofing systems combine durability with an attractive finish. This type of metal roof resembles traditional materials while providing excellent weather resistance and easier installation.
D. Metal Shingles
Offering the look of traditional materials like wood or slate, metal shingles are durable and available in various styles and colors. They are lightweight and weather-resistant, making them a practical choice for homeowners seeking both beauty and functionality.
| PROS | CONS |
| Longevity: Can last 50+ years, much longer than traditional roofs | Higher Cost: More expensive upfront compared to asphalt shingles |
| Durability: Handles extreme weather like high winds, hail, and fire | Noise: Can be louder during rain or hail without proper insulation |
| Low Maintenance: Needs minimal upkeep with just regular cleaning and inspections | Denting: Softer metals like aluminum may dent from heavy impacts |
| Increased Value: Boosts resale value due to its durability and low maintenance needs | Expansion/Contraction: Temperature changes can cause panels to expand, leading to leaks if they’re not installed properly |
Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles are made up of granules, an asphalt coating, and a base mat. Owing to their low cost, simplicity of installation, and resilience to different weather conditions, they are frequently used on residential buildings.
Aesthetic appeal and cost considerations can be met by the variety of asphalt shingles available to homeowners, including 3-tab, architectural, and designer options. Asphalt shingles are made to provide a waterproof layer that keeps your house safe from moisture and environmental harm while guaranteeing long-lasting functionality.
Types Of Asphalt Shingles
A. 3-Tab Shingles
Flat with three cutouts at the bottom, 3-tab shingles create the look of three separate pieces. Made from a single layer of fiberglass mat coated with asphalt and granules, they are the most affordable option but can be vulnerable to wind and water damage.
B. Architectural Shingles
Thicker and more durable than 3-tab options, architectural shingles have a layered design for a three-dimensional look. While they cost more, they mimic premium materials, improving curb appeal and offering better weather resistance.
C. Luxury Asphalt Shingles
Designed to resemble slate or cedar shakes, luxury asphalt shingles provide excellent durability and aesthetic appeal. Although they are the heaviest option and come with a higher price tag, they significantly enhance a home’s appearance.
| PROS | CONS |
| Cost-Effective: Cheaper than materials like metal or tile | Shorter Lifespan: Doesn’t last as long as metal or slate |
| Easy Installation: Quick and simple, lowering labor costs | Wind Vulnerability: May blow off in severe storms |
| Weather Resistant: Holds up well against UV rays, rain, and snow | Granule Loss: Granules can wear off, reducing protection and appearance |
| Fire Resistant: Many meet fire safety standards | Temperature Sensitivity: Extreme temperatures can affect performance |
Related: What Is The Difference Between Dimensional vs. Luxury Shingles?
Metal Roofs vs. Asphalt Shingles
Being able to choose between two effective roofing materials is crucial for homeowners because while both may offer features that can benefit any homeowner, there are factors that vary person to person that need to be accounted for. Some of these factors are addressed below:
#1. Durability
Metal roofs are exceptionally durable, lasting more than 50 years. They withstand extreme weather, such as hail and heavy snow, with minimal damage. In contrast, asphalt shingles have a shorter lifespan of about 25 to 30 years, making them more vulnerable to severe weather, algae growth, and leaks.
#2. Cost
One common question that always comes up is which one is more expensive, a metal roof or shingles? When considering the difference in cost between a metal roof vs. a shingle one, metal roofs typically cost more initially, ranging from $4 to $45 per square foot. However, their long lifespan and lower maintenance needs can save money in the long run. Meanwhile, asphalt shingles are cheaper upfront, costing between $3 and $6 per square foot, but their shorter lifespan may lead to higher long-term expenses due to regular repairs and replacements.
#3. Installation
Installing metal roofs requires specialized skills and tools, making the process more complex and time-consuming. This can increase labor costs. On the other hand, asphalt shingles are quicker and easier to install, often allowing for installation over existing materials, which saves time and reduces costs.
#4. Energy Efficiency
Metal roofs effectively reflect sunlight, helping keep homes cooler in summer and reducing air conditioning costs by 10-15%. Many metal roofs are even made from recycled materials and are recyclable after their lifespan is up. In comparison, asphalt shingles tend to absorb heat, which increases cooling costs, although there are some newer products on the market now that offer reflective coatings to minimize this.
#5. Appearance
Homeowners have plenty of choices aesthetically for their homes. Modern metal roofs come in various colors and styles, even mimicking traditional materials, seamlessly creating the perfect match for various home designs. In comparison, asphalt shingles offer a classic look that many prefer for traditional homes, but they lack the ability to be fully customizable like metal.
#6. Maintenance
Metal roofs require minimal upkeep that involves periodic inspections for rust and simple cleaning with soap and water. On the other hand, asphalt shingles require more regular maintenance due to curling, cracking, and algae growth, leading to frequent repairs.
#7. Noise
A common concern with metal roofs is noise during rain or hail, but proper insulation can reduce this significantly. Asphalt shingles offer better sound insulation, making interiors quieter during storms.
#8. Weight
Another consideration is weight. Metal roofs are lighter than shingles and usually do not need additional structural support, making them easier to handle during installation. In contrast, asphalt shingles are heavier and may require stronger support in older homes, affecting the overall load-bearing capacity.
#9. Resale Value
Homes with metal roofs often have higher resale values, appealing to buyers due to their durability and energy efficiency. On the other hand, while asphalt shingles are popular, they typically do not add as much value to a home due to their shorter lifespan and the potential need for replacement.
#10. Fire Resistance
In terms of fire safety, metal roofs are non-combustible and offer excellent fire resistance, making them ideal for areas prone to wildfires or extreme heat. Most asphalt shingles have a Class A fire rating as well, but they can still be susceptible to igniting under extreme conditions.
#11. Weather Resistance
When it comes to weather performance, metal roofs excel at shedding snow and resisting moisture, reducing the risk of leaks. In comparison, asphalt shingles perform well under normal weather but can become vulnerable during severe winter storms, contributing to ice dams.
#12. Insurance Considerations
Some insurance companies offer discounts for homes with metal roofs due to their durability and fire resistance. Homes with asphalt shingles may not receive the same discounts, as they are viewed as less durable.
#13. Color Retention
When it comes to color retention, metal roofs typically maintain their color better over time, thanks to advanced coatings that resist fading from UV exposure. Asphalt shingles may fade due to sun exposure, though newer products often include UV-resistant granules to help maintain their color.
#14. Warranty Options
Metal roofs often come with warranties extending up to 50 years or more, indicating their durability. In comparison, warranties for asphalt shingles usually range from 20 to 30 years, depending on quality.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?
Both metal roofs and shingles have unique benefits, so the right choice depends on your needs. Metal roofs offer durability, energy efficiency, and long-term savings, while shingles are more affordable and versatile. To help you make the best choice for your needs, reach out to a roofing professional.
Related: Switching from Metal Roof to Shingles: A Complete Guide
Deciding Between A Metal vs. Shingle Roof? OConnor Contracting Can Help!
Still unsure which roofing option is the best choice for your home? Every house is unique, and OConnor Contracting can provide personalized advice on both high-quality shingle roof installations and advanced metal roofing services tailored to your specific needs. We’ll assess your home’s structure, consider your local climate, and help you understand the benefits of each option. Call us at (716) 600-7663 to learn more about what we can do for you!
