Metal Roof Vs Shingles: What’s Best For Your Home?

Posted on September 21, 2022

Estimated Reading Time : 5 Min.

Share Now :
Metal Roof Vs Shingles: What’s Best For Your Home?

If you are comparing metal roof vs shingles, you may have learned that metal roofs are more durable, sturdy, and costly than shingles. But this is just a basic picture. There are a lot of factors that affect the performance of your roof and your personal needs. Homeowners who want to focus on cost and aesthetics also need to learn some essential details to compare the value of metal and shingle roofs.

As industry experts, we are here with another article that simplifies complex roofing topics such as this one. This guide will be extremely helpful if you are getting a new roof. We have created an in-depth comparison of metal roofs vs shingles so you can make an informed decision.

Metal Roof Vs Shingles: What’s The Difference?

Shingles are the most common roofing material in the US, but many people are also shifting to metal roofs. Below are 8 features that will help you understand which roofing material is more suitable for your home. We will also rate them on a scale of 1 to 10 to make it even easier.

Metal Roof Vs Shingles

#1 Total Cost

Metal Roofs: 7

Shingle roofs: 7

When you compare the cost of metal roof vs shingle, it’s clear that the initial expense of a metal roof is more than asphalt shingles. However, as we mentioned above, there are many factors to consider when deciding between these two options. Over the years, metal roofs can make up for the initial cost as they need very little upkeep, and you won’t have to replace them for decades. In contrast, shingle roofs need regular maintenance, and you may have to replace them after 15 years which can ultimately increase your roofing cost.

#2 Curb Appeal

Shingle roofs: 10

Metal roofs: 10

Whether you choose shingles or a metal roof, you will see appealing choices in both materials. Architectural shingles come in plenty of luxurious patterns and beautiful 3D designs, so you can easily find a unique and affordable match. Architectural shingles are sturdy, but they are lighter than metal roofs. So if you want to install new shingles on your existing roof, you won’t even have to replace the decking if it is still intact.

Metal roofs have a modern touch, and metals such as copper and tin offer the most attractive roofing systems that can stay strong for decades! You can even paint a steel or aluminum roof to match the color of your home, which is especially helpful if you have brick or stone siding.

Metal panels and asphalt shingles can also mimic the traditional look of wood, tile, slate, and clay.

#3 Fire-Resistance

Metal roofs: 10

Shingle roofs: 8

If you live in a hot region or have cables and wires near the roof, you must make sure that your roof is resistant to fire. Metal roofs and shingles are fire-resistant but in different ways. Metals have a very high melting point, so they don’t catch fire or burn easily. Therefore, metal roofs generally have a class 4 fire rating which means they pass the highest fire-resistance tests.

While looking at shingle roofs, there are two types of asphalt shingles, and both have different fire-proofing capabilities. Organic shingles are made of asphalt, felt, cellulose, and wood chips– this combination isn’t fireproof. If you choose composite shingles, they have fiberglass, rubber, and asphalt, which makes them highly resistant to fire.

#4 Performance In Cold Climates

Metal roofs: 10

Shingle roofs: 8

Metal roofs are excellent for colder states like New York, and some shingles also work well in cooler climates. GAF is currently the leading manufacturer of Class 4 shingle lines. This means the shingles can withstand high impact and weather ratings. If you desire shingles over metals, choose a GAF-certified contractor for installation, as they are trained and qualified to install the highest quality roofs.

#5 Resistance To Water And Wind

Metal roofs: 10

Shingle roofs: 8

Shingles are often praised as the best choice for your home due to their affordability and looks, but regular shingles are also susceptible to wind and water damage. Unless you choose algae-resistant architectural shingles, water damage can be an issue. In the case of metal roofs, they are more resistant to weather damage, algae, and pest infestation. Standing seam metal roofs can easily withstand extreme temperatures, heavy rain, and agitating winds.

#6 Durability

Metal roofs: 10

Shingle roofs: 8

This is where metal roofs are superior to shingles. The average lifespan of a metal roof is 50 years, and copper roofs can last even longer– almost 100 years! If you plan to stay in your home for decades, this is a great option for you and your family. You can reap all its benefits without ever worrying about replacing the roof.

On the other hand, the lifespan of asphalt shingles is highly variable due to weather conditions in different regions. In rainy areas like Buffalo, NY., average rainfall may exceed 16 inches. So you can expect your shingles to last about 15-20 years. If you live in a place with a normal climate, you can extend the lifespan of your shingle roof by 10 more years. All you have to do is maintain it properly over the years.

#7 Energy Efficiency

Metal roofs: 10

Shingle roofs: 10

It’s another feature that makes metal roofs preferable. They are one of the most energy-efficient roofs available, and you can save up to 40% of your energy bills with a metal roof. If you want to consider a shingle roof, solar shingles are highly energy efficient and qualify as cool roofs, passing tax credit.

#8 Soundproofing Ability

Metal roofs: 8

Shingle roofs: 8

High-quality asphalt shingles are highly noise-resistant, which means that they do not absorb and transmit noise from outside. If you want to pick a metal roof for your home, then you a sturdy insulation material to make it soundproof. Otherwise, it can become a bit noisy during rain or hail.

Final Thoughts

Metal roofs and shingles are both excellent options. If you want to avoid roof replacement for long over 30 years, you can choose a historic metal roof such as copper, but it can be expensive for some homeowners. However, the durability and resilience power of your roof will solely depend on the quality of roofing materials and installation. Low-quality metals and shingles will not perform well, and faulty installation can affect the quality of even the finest roofing materials. If you’re looking for good shingle or metal roofing suppliers in Buffalo or West New York, consult your local roofing contractors for a free consultation.

Discuss Metal Roof vs Shingle With the Experts

At OConnor Contracting, we are proud to be the reliable shingle and metal roofers in Buffalo, serving all over Western New York. We are your local GAF-certified professionals, so you can rely on our experienced and skilled team for the best residential roofing services in Buffalo, Amherst, and the surrounding areas. The roofing industry is changing day by day, and as your trusted local experts, we aim to educate you about the latest developments and best possibilities to protect your homes and buildings.

If you want a free roof consultation or an estimate on metal roof vs shingle cost, reach us at (716) 600-7663. We will be happy to help you.

Skip to content