Taking that switch from a metal roof to asphalt shingles is a big decision for homeowners. Metal roofs are durable and long-lasting, but you might consider switching to shingles for reasons like cost, appearance, or easier installation. This blog post will help you understand the process of switching from a metal roof to shingles and show you the benefits of asphalt shingles.
Why Consider Switching Your Metal Roof to Shingles?
Even though metal roofs last a long time, you might want to switch to shingles for several reasons:
1. Appearance
Shingles come in many colors, styles, and textures, helping you achieve the look you want and boost your home’s curb appeal.
2. Cost
Shingles can be more affordable upfront compared to some metal roofs.
3. Noise Reduction
Thicker shingles can reduce noise from rain, hail, and other weather more effectively than metal roofs.
4. Repairs and Maintenance
Shingles are usually easier and cheaper to repair or replace than metal panels, making them a good option for long-term upkeep.
5. Energy Efficiency
Newer shingle technologies offer better insulation, which can help lower your energy bills.
6. Easier Installation
Shingles are often quicker and simpler to install, which can be a plus for DIY projects.
7. Variety of Styles
With many colors and styles available, asphalt shingles allow homeowners to customize their roof to fit their home’s look.
Also Read: Metal Roof Vs Shingles: What’s Best For Your Home?
Preparing for the Switch
1. Check the Metal Roof’s Condition
Start by inspecting your metal roof for signs of wear, rust, or damage. If the roof is still in good shape, decide whether you can recycle the metal panels or if they can be reused for a different project.
2. State of the Underlying Structure
Replacing a roof involves completely removing the current materials and replacing them with new ones. If the roof deck or underlying structure is damaged, this will raise costs and extend the timeline of the project.
3. Get Permits and Approvals
Before starting, check with your local building authority to see if you need any permits. Building codes can vary, so it’s important to ensure you meet all local regulations to avoid any legal issues.
Removing the Metal Roof
1. Safety First
Always prioritize safety. Wear protective gear, such as gloves, goggles, and a hard hat. If you’re uncomfortable working at heights, consider hiring a professional to handle the job.
2. Gather Tools
| TOOLS REQUIRED CHECKLIST |
| Pry bar or crowbar |
| Hammer |
| Reciprocating saw |
| Safety harness and ropes |
| Tarps for collecting debris |
3. Step-by-Step Removal
- Remove Flashing: Start by detaching any flashing around chimneys, vents, and roof edges.
- Take Off Metal Panels: Begin at the top and use a pry bar to lift the panels away from the roof, working in sections to avoid damage.
- Inspect the Roof Deck: Once the metal panels are removed, examine the roof deck for any damage or rot. Repair any issues before moving on.
Preparing the Roof Deck
1. Inspect and Repair Damage
After removing the metal roof, thoroughly inspect the roof deck for water damage, rot, or structural issues. Replace any damaged plywood or beams to ensure a solid foundation for the new shingles.
2. Ensure Proper Ventilation and Insulation
Good ventilation is key to the longevity of your new roof. Check that your attic has proper airflow to prevent moisture buildup, which can lead to mold and structural damage. Consider adding insulation if necessary.
3. Install New Underlayment
A high-quality underlayment is crucial for protecting against moisture. Choose an underlayment that provides an extra layer of defense against water infiltration, helping to ensure the durability of your new shingles.
Installing the Asphalt Shingles
With the roof deck ready, it’s time to install your new asphalt shingles. Follow these steps for a successful installation:
1. Choosing the Right Type and Style
- Select Shingles: Choose asphalt shingles based on color, texture, and style. Options include architectural shingles for a dimensional look and 3-tab shingles for a traditional appearance.
- Consider the Climate: Pick shingles suited to your local climate. Some shingles perform better in high winds or heavy snow. Consult with a roofing professional or shingle manufacturer to ensure you make the best choice.
2. Laying The Shingles
A. Start at the Bottom
Begin laying shingles from the bottom edge of the roof and work your way up. This ensures water flows over the shingles, preventing leaks.
B. Secure the Shingles
Use roofing nails as recommended by the manufacturer. Ensure nails are driven straight and flush with the roof surface.
C. Apply Sealant
Use high-quality sealant on the edges of the shingles and around visible nails to prevent them from lifting and to protect against high winds.
3. Finishing Touches
- Install Ridge Vents and Hip Caps: Ridge vents promote airflow in your attic, helping hot air escape and reducing moisture buildup. Install them along the roof peak. Hip caps cover exposed edges at the roof hips, adding extra protection against water intrusion.
- Apply Sealant: Apply sealant around any roof penetrations, like vents and chimneys, to prevent leaks. Ensure all seams are sealed neatly and uniformly.
- Clean Up: After installation, clean the job site thoroughly. Remove debris such as nails, shingle fragments, and tools. Properly dispose of roofing waste according to local regulations.
Potential Challenges of Switching
Switching from a metal roof to shingles has its benefits, but there are a few challenges to consider:
1. Lifespan Differences
Metal roofs usually last longer than shingles. If you switch to shingles for cost reasons, remember that you might need to replace the roof more often.
2. Roof Structure Adjustments
If your roof was made for lightweight metal, you might need to adjust it to handle the heavier shingles. This could increase the overall cost.
3. Disposal of Old Materials
Removing the metal roof might require special disposal methods, especially if it includes materials like steel or aluminum that need to be recycled.
Final Considerations
Before taking the switch from shingles to a metal roof, weigh the initial savings against long-term costs. Shingles are cheaper upfront but may require more maintenance and replacements. Consider your local climate—shingles might not be as protective in extreme weather as metal. If you value appearance or affordability, shingles could be a great choice. Ultimately, base your decision on your budget, preferences, and your home’s needs.
Upgrade Your Roof: Switch from Metal to Shingles with OConnor Contracting
Remember, every roof is unique, so it’s important to consult with roofing professionals to address your home’s specific needs. With proper installation and maintenance, your new shingle roof will offer reliable protection and boost your home’s curb appeal for years to come.
Whether you need metal’s durability or shingles’ classic look, we’ve got you covered. Our team at OConnor Contracting ensures smooth installation or replacement with solutions for durability and aesthetic appeal. Call us at (716) 600-7663 for a consultation and experience the best metal roofing and shingle services!
