Best Asphalt Roof Shingles That Steal The Spotlight

Posted on March 23, 2024

Estimated Reading Time : 6 Min.

Share Now :
Best Asphalt Roof Shingles That Steal The Spotlight

Asphalt roof shingles have undergone significant advancements over the years and are now more affordable, durable, and visually appealing. It’s no surprise that they are the most widely used roofing material in North America, adorning more than 70% of roofs. 

So if you’re a homeowner looking to spruce up your home with these roofing shingles, you are at the right place. Today, we have curated a list of the best asphalt roof shingles that are sure to elevate the curb appeal of your home and make your property stand out. 

#1 GAF Timberline HDZ®

GAF is one of the largest roofing manufacturers in North America, with a history dating back over 130 years. The Timberline HDZ shingle is the company’s prime offering. This architectural asphalt roof shingle has been a top choice of homeowners for years and is sure to dominate in 2024, too. It is made from a dual layer of top-quality asphalt that is reinforced with a fiberglass mat. 


Since Timberline HDZ shingles are backed by GAF, they come with various features. The LayerLock™ technology offered by GAF makes these shingles much easier for contractors to install. Also, the larger StrikeZone™ and shingle-to-shingle adhesive reduce the likelihood of mistakes, ensuring better functionality.

Color Options

GAF uses its patented High Definition® (HD) color options that have unique, dark shadow lines. Though there are 25 shingle color options, most of the colors are region-specific. Here are some of the colors homeowners love: 

  • Weathered Wood 
  • Charcoal 
  • Hickory


When you install a new roof, which is already a very expensive project, you will certainly want to look into warranties. GAF is known to offer some of the best warranties in the industry. 

  • The Timberline HDZ shingles come with a 25-year warranty against blue-green algae discoloration. 
  • Also, these architectural shingles are the first in the industry to offer a wind warranty without a maximum wind speed limit. 
GAF Timberline HDZ®
GAF Timberline HDZ®

#2 Owens Corning Duration® Series

Owens Corning is a well-established name in the roofing industry, known for its innovative and high-quality products. The Duration series is one of their flagship offerings. This series has several variants, and all come with superb features. 


Owens Corning Duration shingles are engineered with the company’s proprietary SureNail® Technology. This helps provide these roof shingles with exceptional wind resistance and durability.

These shingles also feature StreakGuard® Algae Protection, keeping your roof looking clean and pristine. The Duration shingles have a Class 3 impact rating, but other options such as Duration FLEX® Shingles, are Class 4 rated if you live in hail-prone areas. 

Color Options

The patented TruDefinition® color platform provides vibrant, high-contrast colors that enhance the curb appeal of any home. Owens Corning offers you more than 21 color options that can suit different architectural styles and preferences. Some popular color choices include: 

  • Estate Gray
  • Onyx Black
  • Driftwood


  • Owens Corning Duration shingles come with a limited lifetime warranty for as long as you own your home.
  • They also offer a 130 mph Wind Resistance Limited Warranty. 
  • You also get a 25-year Algae Resistance Limited Warranty.
Owens Corning Duration® Series
Owens Corning Duration® Series

#3 Tamko Titan XT®

You might not hear about Tamko as much as other shingle brands such as GAF and Owens Corning, but they are steadily gaining popularity thanks to their premium shingle, Titan XT

This product is one of the most durable asphalt roof shingles and has been voted the Product of the Year for 2024 under the Home Protection Category by Kantar. 


Tamko Titan XT shingles incorporate powerful engineering and advanced sealant technology to protect homes during the harshest of weather conditions. These shingles are designed with the company’s best and heaviest architectural shingle weathering technology. It also includes the special AnchorLock™ layer, which is a reinforcing strip on the back of shingles, offering even better resistance against uplift. 

Color Options

The TAMKO Titan XT shingles use APEX color technology, so they have richer, more vibrant shingle colors. They are also coated with a protective coating. Here are some popular TAMKO shingle colors: 

  • Rustic Black
  • Rustic Slate
  • Shadow Grey


  • TAMKO provides a limited lifetime warranty for Titan XT shingles, ensuring long-term protection and value for homeowners. Plus, there is a 10-year non-prorated warranty period in which the full cost of any replacement shingles and installation labor are covered. 
  • The WindGUARD™ Warranty offers protection from winds of up to 160 mph, which is the company’s highest available wind resistance.
Tamko Titan XT®
Tamko Titan XT®

#4 Atlas Pinnacle® Pristine Shingles

Pinnacle Pristine architectural shingles, manufactured by Atlas, are popular asphalt roof shingles in North America. This shingle option is renowned for their premium quality and stunning aesthetics. These architectural shingles are designed to elevate the look of any home while providing superior protection against the elements.


Pinnacle Pristine shingles are manufactured using HP42™ technology. This means each shingle is 42-inches in size, which is bigger than most competitors. The larger size means you will need fewer shingles to cover your roof. Also, these asphalt shingles are designed with the Sweet Spot™ nailing area, making them easier and faster to install for roofing professionals.

These are one of the best roof shingles when it comes to algae protection. They come with Scotchgard™ Protector, a technology made by the industry leader, 3M. 

Color Options

Compared to other asphalt shingles, the color options are comparatively limited. But there are still some good choices. Some popular colors include: 

  • Hearthstone 
  • Summer Storm
  • Weathered Shadow


  • Atlas offers a lifetime limited warranty, providing peace of mind for homeowners.
  • The shingles also come with a Wind Limited Warranty of up to 130 mph and an Algae Resistance Limited Warranty for 15 years.
Atlas Pinnacle® Pristine Shingles

#5 Malarkey Legacy® Scotchgard™ 

Last but not the least is Markey Legacy Scotchgard shingles. Malarkey has always been known for trying something new with their manufacturing, and these shingles reflect that. 


This shingle uses cutting-edge NEX® Rubberized Asphalt technology. The asphalt roof shingles boast the industry’s highest impact rating of Class 4, ensuring exceptional durability against the elements. They use 50% more adhesive bonds and have a nailing area that is twice the size than other shingles. 

Malarkey is one of the only manufacturers that incorporates recycled rubber and plastic materials in their roofing products. They also feature smog reducing granules that add to their sustainability. These roof shingles go above and beyond by meeting the stringent FORTIFIED™ Roof requirements set by the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS). 

Color Options

The color options are somewhat limited compared to other brands. If you live in New York, you will have the option to choose from 11 colors. The following are some of the top picks: 

  • Midnight Black
  • Sienna Blend
  • Natural Wood 


  • With these shingles, you get a standard limited lifetime warranty, with a non-prorated period of 20 years. 
  • There is also a limited lifetime algae resistance warranty.
  • These roof shingles include a standard wind warranty of 110 mph, but you can opt for enhanced warranty coverage that will cover up to 130 mph. 
Malarkey Legacy® Scotchgard™ 
Malarkey Legacy® Scotchgard™ 

Best Shingle Installation Services In WNY

The shingles listed above are some of the best on the market and are sure to elevate the curb appeal of your home. If you are looking for a trustworthy and reliable company to install asphalt shingles, we would be more than happy to assist you. Our team of experts is well-equipped to handle all your asphalt roofing needs and ensure that your home is protected for years to come. Contact us today at (716) 600-7663 to schedule a consultation!

Best Asphalt Roof Shingles That Steal The Spotlight
Skip to content