At A Glance: Top 10 Buffalo Roofers
| Rank | Company Name | Best For |
| #1 | O’Connor Contracting | Overall Best / 24-7 Emergency |
| #2 | Five Star Roofing | Project Management |
| #3 | DSS Roofing | Total Exteriors |
| #4 | Dalex Roofing | Metal Roofing |
| #5 | Mann Construction | Home Renovations |
| #6 | Black Rock Roofing | Detailed Estimates/Gutters |
| #7 | Buffalo Roofing | Storm Damage |
| #8 | Wm. C. Rott & Son | Historic Homes |
| #9 | Lifetime Siding | Gutter & Siding |
| #10 | Naples Roofing | Commercial Maintenance |
Finding a reliable roofer in Buffalo is difficult. The market is flooded with lead-generation sites, and contractors who might not be around when the snow starts falling.
At O’Connor Contracting, we know the difference between a quick patch job and a roof built to survive a Lake Erie winter. As a local roofing company with over a decade of experience in Western New York, we work alongside these companies, compete with them, and see their work firsthand.
How We Created This List
We didn’t just pick random names from a phone book. We selected these top 10 companies based on the criteria that actually matter to homeowners, with a heavy focus on stability.
Why is stability our #1 factor? Because the data proves that longevity in this industry is rare.
According to business survival data tracking via the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, construction firms established in 2013, the odds are stacked against young companies:
- The 5-Year Mark: By year five, nearly 45% of construction businesses had already failed.
- The 10-Year Mark: A decade later, that survival rate drops to roughly 43%.
What does this mean for you? It means that statistically, nearly 6 out of 10 roofing companies started ten years ago are no longer in business today.
If you hire a young, unproven company, there is a very real chance they won’t be around to honor your warranty if a leak springs down the road, or there is a manufacturer defect and you need to file a warranty claim. That is why our list prioritizes:
- Longevity: Companies that have beaten the odds and served Buffalo for years.
- Local Presence: Actual local offices, not out-of-state storm chasers.
- Specialization: Contractors who understand specific Buffalo challenges, from slate restoration on historic homes to emergency ice dam removal.
While we are confident in our own services as the #1 choice, we believe in honest competition. Below is our professional assessment of the best roofing companies in Buffalo, NY that have stood the test of time.
Best Roofing Companies In Buffalo To Look Out For
When it comes to the roof over your head, you want a company that will be there when you need them.
It’s important to find a company that understands what it’s like to live in Buffalo and understands its unpredictable weather. You want to choose a company that knows how to work with the unique challenges of city living: tight spaces, long waits for permits, and limited parking.
In Buffalo, there are a number of top-notch roofing companies who can repair your roof quickly and efficiently, so you can get back to enjoying your home without worry. Below are the best roofing companies in Buffalo, NY.
#1 O’Connor Contracting
Address: 106 Hubbardston Pl, Buffalo, NY 14228
Phone Number: (716) 600-7663
Website: https://oconnorroofingbuffalo.com/contact-us/
Why We are #1: Established in 2014, OConnor Contracting has been soaring high as one of Buffalo’s leading roofing companies. With a team of highly skilled experts on their team, they have been providing top-notch roofing services and customer experience to the Buffalo area for well over 10 years.
- Offers a full range of roofing services, from repairs to complete replacements, working with popular roofing materials like asphalt shingles, metal, slate, TPO, modified bitumen, and EPDM.
- Partners with top manufacturers like GAF to ensure roofs are built with durable, high-quality materials that withstand Buffalo’s weather.
- Renowned for customer-focused service, providing prompt responses, quality results, and transparent, fair pricing.
- Available 24/7 for emergency services, including fast roof tarping, inspections, and repairs for storm damage.
- A trusted choice for homeowners seeking a dedicated team that delivers dependable results and peace of mind with every project.
#2 Five Star Roofing Consultants & Services
Address: 326 Hinman Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
Phone Number: (716) 828-6279
Website: https://fivestarserviceswny.com/
Five Star Roofing Consultants & Services is dedicated to providing the best customer service. They are members of the Better Business Bureau, fully licensed & insured, and they are locally owned and operated. They assign a project manager to every project to create an open line of communication that allows for the most effective customer service.
Best For: They assign a dedicated project manager to every job, which helps keep communication open and ensures you aren’t left guessing about the status of your roof.
#3 DSS Roofing
Address: 127 Hiler Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217
Phone Number: (716) 907-7373
Website: https://www.dssroofing.com/
DSS Roofing is among the top roofing companies in Buffalo. The company’s expertise and professionalism in the roofing industry are well known throughout the region. They are a great choice for roof replacement and repair, chimney repairs and construction, and emergency roof snow removal. Customers can be confident that they will get fast and efficient work at reasonable prices from DSS Roofing.
Best For: Total Exteriors. An excellent option if you need chimney masonry work or emergency snow removal alongside your roofing project
#4 Dalex Roofing
Address: 1974 Eggert Rd, Buffalo, NY 14226
Phone Number: (716) 609-2918
Website: https://www.dalexroofing.com/
Dalex Roofing has been a family-owned business since 2004, providing high-quality roofing materials and installation services. They offer a wide range of services, including shingle replacement, metal roofing installation, and complete roof restoration. They are dedicated to providing customers with excellent service from start to finish.
Best For: Metal Roofing. A strong focus on family values and customer service makes them a reliable choice for residential metal roofing installation.
#5 Mann Construction & Roofing
Address: 237 Pratt St, Buffalo, NY 14204
Phone Number: (716) 500-6266
Website: https://www.mannconstruction-wny.com/
Mann Construction is a full-service roofing company based out of Buffalo, NY. They are a top-rated construction company known for completing projects on time. From the first nail to the final creative touches, they’ll turn your home into a modern, unique, and comfortable place to live. In addition to their door and window installation services, they are proud to offer interior painting and much more.
Best For: Renovations. As a true “Construction” company, they can handle door and window installations and even interior painting, making them a good choice for whole-home renovations.
#6 Black Rock Roofing
Address: 2064 Niagara St, Buffalo, NY 14207
Phone Number: (716) 875-5138
Website: https://www.blackrockroofingny.com/
Black Rock Roofing is one of the most reliable roofing companies in Buffalo, NY. They provide superior roofs and siding for all kinds of homes, including single-family houses and two-story homes. Established in 1946, they have been serving residents and businesses in the Buffalo area for over seventy years. Their commitment to customer satisfaction is always their top priority, and this commitment is evident from their many satisfied customers.
Best For: Their recent reviews suggest strong satisfaction when it comes to detailed estimates and gutter service.
#7 Buffalo Roofing
Address: 5565 Transit Rd, Williamsville, NY 14221
Phone Number: (716) 444-7663
Website: https://www.buffaloroofing.com/
Buffalo Roofing is a top-notch local commercial and residential roofing contractor. From comprehensive solutions to modern resources, they provide a wide range of reliable services that are completed on time, within budget, and of the highest quality. The company’s technicians use the best equipment and their years of experience to guarantee the timely completion of projects on schedule and within budget.
Best For: Roof Storm Damage. Many customer reviews cite wind damage to their home and satisfaction repairs and roof replacements performed.
#8 Wm. C. Rott & Son
Address: 454 Young St, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Phone Number: (716) 670-3578
Website: https://wcrott.com/
Established in 1909, Wm. C. Rott & Son has been a cornerstone in the Buffalo roofing industry for over a century. This family-owned business offers a comprehensive range of services, including roofing, siding, windows, and gutters. Their commitment to quality craftsmanship and customer satisfaction has earned them a trusted reputation in the community. With a team of experienced professionals, they ensure each project is completed with attention to detail and durability. Their longevity in the industry speaks to their reliability and dedication to serving the Buffalo area.
Best For: Roof tune ups. Multiple reviews mention roof tune ups being complete and friendly service.
#9 Lifetime Siding, Roofing, And Construction
Address: 5500 N Bailey Ave, Buffalo, NY 14226
Phone Number: (716) 239-6476
Website: https://lifetimesidingandroofing.com/
Lifetime Siding, Roofing, and Construction are one of the best storm damage roofing companies in Buffalo, NY. Their professionals can take care of everything from a new roof installation to chimney services and more. Lifetime Siding, Roofing, and Construction is here to protect your home so you can enjoy it with peace of mind.
Best For: Gutter & siding Repair. Several reviews mention they were quick to assess the issues of birds nesting asa result of needing siding and gutter repairs. All four customers stated they had a five star experience.
#10 Naples Roofing
Address: 2011 Niagara St, Buffalo, NY 14207
Phone Number: (716) 715-0756
Website: https://naples-roofing.com/
Naples Roofing has been providing quality roofing services to its customers for years. They know how important a roof is for your business. Their roofers are highly trained and experienced, so you can be sure that your roof will remain sturdy and last for decades. Their team is licensed and insured, and they provide free written estimates before any work begins.
Best For: Maintenance. Great for commercial and business roofing needs, with a focus on durability and long-term maintenance.
How to Choose the Right Roofer in Buffalo
Finding the right contractor can be daunting. Here are three quick tips to help you decide between the companies above:
- Check the Timeline: Buffalo weather doesn’t wait. Ask every contractor: “How soon can you start?”
- Look for “Buffalo” Experience: Slate roofs on historic West Side homes require different skills than asphalt shingles in the suburbs. Make sure your roofer has experience with your specific home style.
- Get it in Writing: Never accept a verbal estimate. Ensure the scope of work details exactly what materials (brand and type) will be used.
Need a Quote Today?
At O’Connor Contracting, we are ready to help you right now. Whether you need an emergency repair or a full estimate for a new roof, our team is standing by.
Click Here to Get a Free Instant Quote Or call us directly at (716) 600-7663
How can you tell a good roofer?
How can you tell a good roofer in Buffalo? Beyond checking Google Reviews, verify these three specific “Buffalo” requirements:
City Licensing: If you live in the City of Buffalo, the contractor must hold a valid Home Improvement Contractor license from the Office of Licenses. Suburban towns (Amherst, Cheektowaga) often require separate town registrations.
Insurance Proof: Ask for a Certificate of Insurance (COI) proving they have General Liability and Workers’ Compensation. If they are “exempt,” you could be liable if a worker falls.
The “Two Layer” Law: A good roofer knows NY State Code prohibits installing a new roof over two existing layers. If you already have two layers, a reputable roofer will insist on a tear-off to comply with code.
What are the red flags for roofing contractors?
“We are in the neighborhood” (Storm Chasers): Be wary of out-of-state trucks showing up immediately after a wind storm. They often take deposits and disappear.
Asking for Full Payment Upfront: legitimate NY contractors might ask for a deposit (e.g., 30% for materials), but asking for 100% before work starts is a major warning sign.
No Written Contract: NY State law requires a written contract for home improvements. This contract must legally include an estimated timeline and a 3-day cancellation window. If they try to do it on a handshake, walk away.
How much does a new roof cost in Buffalo, NY? (Rates)
The average cost for a typical asphalt shingle roof replacement in Buffalo ranges between $7,500 and $14,000.
Per Square Foot: Expect to pay between $4.00 and $7.00 per square foot for standard architectural shingles installed.
Factors: Prices fluctuate based on steepness, waste removal fees, access, existing layers on the roof and whether you need a full tear-off.
Premium Materials: Metal roofing in Western NY averages $7 to $17 per sq. ft., while authentic slate (common on historic Buffalo homes) can range from $12 to $24+ per sq. ft..
